there are a few more advanced techniques and tips to consider when building tonality in black and white manga, especially when using Clip Studio Paint.

These techniques will help you refine the quality of your artwork:

1. Use of Gradients for Soft Transitions

Gradients are perfect for creating smooth transitions between light and shadow. In CSP, you can use the Gradient Tool to create subtle shifts in tonal value, such as for skies, backgrounds, or soft lighting on characters.

Gradients work well when you're trying to create atmospheric depth or when light transitions need to be smooth but you don't want to manually blend them.

How to Use:

Choose the Gradient Tool from the toolbar.

Select a Black to Transparent gradient from the settings.

Apply the gradient across the area where you want a smooth transition, such as from dark to light, creating a fade effect.

This is particularly useful in establishing a soft environment or distance in the background without needing heavy lines or texture.

2. Utilizing Layer Modes for Tonal Effects

CSP offers multiple Layer Modes that can help enhance tonal work in black and white manga. The most common modes for tonal adjustments are Multiply, Overlay, and Screen. Each of these can be used to alter how shadows and highlights interact with your inked linework.

Key Modes:

Multiply: Darkens the layers beneath, making it great for applying shadow layers.

Overlay: Enhances contrast, making both shadows and highlights more vibrant.

Screen: Lightens areas, which is useful for adding light without erasing darker tones.

3. Textured Brushes for Added Depth

CSP offers a variety of textured brushes (e.g., rough shading brushes or hatching brushes) that can introduce complexity and texture into the tones of your manga.

For areas like rocky surfaces, tree bark, or even clothing folds, textured brushes can be used instead of flat shadows to give a more tactile and dynamic look.

How to Use:

Experiment with brushes like the Rough Pencil or Crosshatch Brushes in CSP's preset library.

Use these brushes in areas where simple shading may not be enough, such as a dirt road or the fabric of a character's worn clothing.

4. Experimenting with Noise Textures

For a unique tonality, consider using noise textures (such as speckling or grunge effects). These add visual interest to large empty spaces or darker areas and can simulate graininess seen in traditional manga.

How to Use:

In the Material Palette, look for noise or grunge textures and apply them with low opacity.

Use the Clip Layer option so that these textures stay within the bounds of your shadowed areas, preventing over-application.

5. Building Atmospheric Perspective

In scenes with large distances (e.g., a cityscape or landscape), you can use tonality to create atmospheric perspective. This is the technique where objects in the distance are lighter and less detailed, while closer objects are darker and more defined.

How to Use:

Apply a lighter tone to objects further in the background using soft gradients or lighter screentones.

Keep the foreground objects in solid black or darker screentones to create depth in your panels.

6. Dynamic Lighting Effects with Highlights

Even in black and white manga, you can create dynamic lighting by using sharp highlights in contrast with deep shadows. Highlights can be used sparingly but strategically, like on metallic surfaces, glass, or in intense action scenes to emphasize movement or emotion.

How to Use:

Add thin white strokes or dots using the G-Pen for high-impact highlights on characters or objects where the light hits directly.

Alternatively, use Airbrush Tools to apply soft highlights where light diffuses, such as on curved surfaces like a character’s cheek or clothing.

7. Mixing Hard and Soft Shadows

Combining both hard-edged shadows (sharp, high-contrast areas) with soft shadows (gradually fading) can make your art more dynamic.

Hard shadows can be used for dramatic, high-energy scenes, while soft shadows work best for calm, emotional, or natural settings.

How to Use:

Block in hard shadows first using the Pen Tool or Lasso Fill Tool, especially in areas where light and shadow are starkly divided.

Add soft shadows with a blending tool or airbrush for smooth transitions, such as under a character's face or in the folds of their clothing.

8. Layering Multiple Screentones

To create a more sophisticated tonal range, layer different screentones on top of one another. Using various densities and types of screentones can create gradients or simulate complex lighting effects.

How to Use:

Start by applying a base screentone to an area.

Add additional screentones on separate layers, adjusting their scale and opacity to blend smoothly.

You can also use masks to blend screentones seamlessly, erasing parts to create varied tonal effects.

By incorporating these additional techniques into your tonality work in Clip Studio Paint, you can push your black and white manga to a more professional level. These methods help you create more engaging compositions, add atmospheric depth, and give your panels a polished, dynamic look.